Dante Canto V

1 Pages 279 Words

“Dante”
Canto V
In reading Canto V “The Carnal”, Dante is now taken to the Second Circle of Hell with Virgil. Minos was the monster that everyone confesses his or her sins too. Their sin was to abandon themselves to the tempest of their passions. When they tell him their sins, he then wraps his tail around himself many of times representing the number of circles the person must go. They would be forever swept away in the tempest of Hell and forever denied in God and the light of reason. “They find themselves on a dark ledge swept by a great whirlwind, which spins within it the souls of Carnal, those who betrayed reason to their appetites,” pg.1032. The main perpetrators talked about in this selection were the story of Francesca and Paolo. The two had fallen in love, but Francesca was married to Paolo’s brother, Giovanni. Giovanni surprised them and killed the both of them while they were in Francesca’s bedroom.
Even though it was their fault because they were responsible of what happened, I do not feel that their punishment fits their sin. These people were in love and very lustful and shameless because they could not help their feelings. Even though what Francesca did was wrong, she was in love with someone else. It would have been wrong of her to be with Giovanni, who she did not love. Now the two of them are stuck in hell and nothing will ever come of it. I do not think this is fair and I would have been upset just like Dante was....